After an illustrious career for both club and country, Gotham FC and U.S. Women’s National Team defender Kelley O’Hara announced today via Kelley on the Street that she will be retiring from professional soccer at the end of this year, making the 2024 NWSL season her last.
“I have always said I would play under two conditions: that I still love playing soccer, and if my body would let me do it the way I wanted to,” O’Hara told Just Women’s Sports in the lead-up to her retirement announcement. “I realized a while back that I was always going to love it, so it was the physical piece that was going to be the deciding factor.”
The 35-year-old will retire as a two-time World Cup champion, an Olympic gold medalist, and at least a two-time NWSL champion, depending on where Gotham finishes this season. Her legacy as a player is hard to fully encapsulate, and will forever run through some of the biggest snapshots in USWNT and NWSL history.
In 2012, O’Hara played every minute of the USWNT’s Olympic gold medal run, after having recently converted into a defender. Her soaring goal off the bench in the 2015 World Cup semifinal is the stuff of legend. And her return from lingering injury to play in every knockout match of the national team’s 2019 World Cup win cemented a storybook international career.
It was O’Hara who scored the overtime goal in 2021 to earn the Washington Spirit their first-ever NWSL championship, and O’Hara who returned to help see Gotham earn a title in 2023 after years spent in the trenches with the club’s previous iteration, Sky Blue. Her 15-year career spanned two professional women’s soccer leagues in the U.S. (she earned her first professional title in 2010 with WPS’s FC Gold Pride), as well as sweeping changes to the sport both on and off the pitch.
On the field, O’Hara has always been known for a motor that never quits, making the right flank her domain in attacking possession and defensive transition. In recent years, she’s also been celebrated for a competitive fire that raises the level of her teammates, whether she’s in the starting XI or supporting from the bench.
But injuries take a toll, a reality not always seen by the fans watching from home. “I’ve never taken anything for granted, and I feel like I’ve never coasted either,” O’Hara said of her late-career success in the NWSL despite battling injuries. “I’ve always been like, ‘I gotta put my best foot forward every single day I step on this field’ — which is honestly probably half the reason why I’m having to retire now as opposed to getting a couple more years out of it. I’ve just grinded hard.”
Recently, O’Hara has been sidelined at Gotham with ankle and knee injuries, and the situation motivated her to really prioritize listening to her body. “To get injured and come back, and get injured and come back, and just keep doing it, it really takes a toll on you.
“People don’t see the doubt that’s associated with injury,” she continued. “As athletes we feel a certain way, we perform a certain way, our body feels a certain way, we’re very in tune with our bodies. And there’s always so much doubt surrounding injury. It’s like, ‘Can I feel the way I felt before?’ The reality is sometimes you don’t.”
O’Hara didn’t arrive at the decision to move on from her playing career lightly. But once she began seriously considering making 2024 her final year during the last NWSL offseason, it felt right. “Once I was like, ‘Alright, you know what, this will be my last year,’ I have had a lot of peace with it,” she said. “Truly the only thing I felt was gratitude for everything that my career has been, all the things I’ve been able to do and the people I’ve been able to do it with.”
She said she’ll miss daily interactions with her teammates and all the amazing memories they’ve created, though she feels lucky to have formed relationships that go beyond sharing a locker room. “You’re basically getting to hang out and just shoot the shit with your best friends every day,” she reflected. “Which is so unheard of, and I just feel very lucky to do it for so long.”
The Stanford graduate also mentioned that the NWSL’s suspension of regular season play in 2020 due to the Covid-19 pandemic made her realize how much playing allowed her the space to simply be creative every day. The tactical elements of soccer provided O’Hara an outlet for problem solving and made use of her naturally competitive edge.
She’s now gearing up to channel her on-field intensity into her post-playing career full time, which is a new chapter she’s excited to begin. “I don’t know if the world’s ready for it, like the fact that I’m not going to be putting all of my energy into football all the time,” she said with a laugh.
O’Hara said she would like to stay connected to the game in some fashion, whether it be as an owner, coach, or member of a front office. She’s also interested in the growing media space surrounding women’s sports, having provided on-camera analysis for broadcasters like CBS Sports in addition to starting a production company with her fiancée.
“I just feel like I have a lot of passions, and things that excite me,” she says. “And I do want to stay as close as I can to the game, because I feel a responsibility — and I’m not sure in what capacity — to continue to grow it.”
A sense of responsibility to grow the game has been a consistent refrain for the USWNT and NWSL players of O’Hara’s era, who ushered in a new age of equal pay for the national team and collectively bargained protections for those in the league. The landscape for new players looks different than it did 14 years ago, in large part due to this pivotal generation.
“I feel an immense sense of pride around that, because I don’t know if any of us knew that was gonna happen,” she said. “We kind of, as things unfolded, took the next step towards changing what women’s football looks like in this country and around the world.
“I’m really grateful to have been part of this era with the players that I was [with], not backing down and pushing and knowing that was the right thing to do.”
Whatever the future holds, O’Hara is going ahead full throttle. It’s a piece of advice she’d also give to the next generation of professionals looking to make their own impact.
“Whatever you do in life, do it because you love it, and the chips will fall in place,” she said. “If you love something, you’re willing to do what it takes. You’re willing to make the sacrifices, you’re willing to handle the roller coaster.
“To me, it’s simple. Don’t do it for any other reason but that, and I think you’ll be alright.”
