A Look at the Most Heated Derbies

Connor Smith

The world of Major League Soccer (MLS) is not about great soccer but also about intense rivalries that bring out the passion in teams and their fans. Whether you’re new to following MLS teams or a seasoned fan looking for insights, this guide will take you through the most heated derbies in the league.

The Cascadia Cup: Seattle Sounders vs. Portland Timbers vs. Vancouver Whitecaps

One of the most well-known rivalries in Major League Soccer (MLS) is the Casc Cup, an electrifying clash involving three iconic MLS teams: Seattle Sounders, Portland Timbers, and Vancouver Whitecaps. The roots of this fierce competition extend back to the North American Soccer League (NAS) days, but it has only intensified since their transition to MLS.

The Seattle Sounders, known for their resounding chants and capacity to fill Lumen Field with green and blue fervor, are a storied team with a passionate fan base. On the other side of the pitch, you have the Portland Timbers, whose fans, the Timbers Army, create an intimidating atmosphere at Providence Park with their continuous singing and even the occasional log-cutting ceremony. Completing the trio, the Vancouver Whitecaps bring their own unique energy from BC Place, backed by legions of die-hard supporters who make every match day unforgettable.

The Cascadia Cup rivalry is much more than just geographical proximity; it’s a clash of cultures, pride, and bragging rights. Here are some interesting nuggets about this legendary rivalry:

• First Contested: The Cascadia Cup was first awarded in 2004, when all three teams were part of the USL (United Soccer League).
• Head-to-Head: As of the latest season, the aggregate results are remarkably close among the three teams, showcasing just how evenly matched these clubs are.
• Attendance: Matches involving Cascadia Cup rivals are known for drawing massive crowds, with several derbies setting MLS attendance records.

Example moments that illuminate the intensity of the rivalry include the thrilling 2018 playoff showdown where the Portland Timbers edged out the Seattle Sounders in a penalty shootout, a match that still brings tingles to those who witnessed it.

“It’s not just a match; it’s representing your city, your community, and all the fans who bleed the team’s colors,” said a veteran Sounders supporter. “Beating Portland or Vancouver isn’t just worth three points—it’s worth a lifetime of pride.”

Through coaching changes, player transfers, and fluctuating fortunes, one constant remains: the Cascadia Cup’s ability to deliver some of the most high-octane and dramatic fixtures in MLS. With each encounter, these teams etch new chapters into the storied Pacific Northwest soccer rivalry, ensuring that the Cascadia Cup remains one of the most celebrated and talked-about trophies in MLS history.

El Tráfico: LA Galaxy vs. Los Angeles FC

Anyone remotely familiar with Major League Soccer knows that when it comes to intense rivalries, El Tráfico is right at the top. This fierce showdown between the Galaxy and Los Angeles FC has quickly become one of the most exciting derbies in American soccer. Named after the notorious traffic congestion in Los Angeles, El Tráfico offers not just a battle for bragging rights, but also a display of top-tier talent and electric atmospheres.

Established in 1996, the LA Galaxy is one of the most storied MLS franchises. The team has accumulated multiple MLS Cup titles and has been home to some of the biggest international and domestic soccer stars, including David Beckham, Landon Donovan, and Zlatan Ibrahimović. Their successful history has made them a household name, making their rivalry with the newer Los Angeles FC even more significant.

Los Angeles FC, or LAFC, burst onto the scene in 2018 but quickly made waves with their high-energy play and star-studded roster. Led by Mexican forward Carlos Vela, LAFC topped the MLS team standings in their debut season, setting records for points accumulated and goals scored. The presence of Vela, a former La Liga star, has significantly raised the profile of the club, making every match day a highly anticipated event.

The rivalry between these two MLS teams is both natural and competitive. Situated just 11 miles apart, the two clubs vie for dominance in America’s second-largest city. Their meetings are often characterized by high stakes, incredible goals, and memorable moments that fans and analysts can’t stop talking about. Who can forget Zlatan’s ridiculous 40-yard debut strike or Carlos Vela’s mesmerizing dribbles that seem to defy physics?

In recent matchups, the balance of power has seesawed between the two clubs, ensuring that their clashes remain unpredictable and heated. The intensity of these games has not only attracted local supporters but also drawn the attention of the global soccer community. Renowned sports journalist Grant Wahl once noted,

“El Tráfico has all the hallmarks of a classic derby – drama, top talent, and a fierce regional pride that makes every encounter unmissable.”

If you ever find yourself in sunny Los Angeles during an El Tráfico match, consider grabbing tickets and joining in the excitement. You’ll experience a live-action showcase of what makes MLS soccer clubs unique: a blend of international flair and homegrown passion. Don’t be surprised if you also become a fan of either Galaxy’s longstanding legacy or LAFC’s youthful vigor.

Texas Derby: FC Dallas vs. Houston Dynamo

The Texas Derby, a thrilling spectacle between FC Dallas and Houston Dynamo, embodies the fiery spirit and competitive edge of MLS teams in the Lone Star State. This matchup doesn’t merely decide who gets the upper hand in Major League Soccer; it also puts stake the much-coveted “El Capitán,” a replica 18th-century mountain howitzer cannon. Talk about an explosive rivalry—literally and figuratively!

Since its inception, the Texas Derby has been a highlight reel of dramatic goals, intense tackles, and unforgettable moments. As of the latest MLS season, FC Dallas holds the upper hand with more wins in their all-time matchups, but the Houston Dynamo aren’t far behind, always eager to tip the scales. In fact, the Dynamo’s 2011 MLS Cup appearance and their subsequent strong performances have kept FC Dallas on their toes.

Here’s a glance at some of their memorable moments:

• 2006 Inaugural Clash: The first Texas Derby on May 6, 2006, ended in a draw, setting the stage for years of rivalry to come.
• Battle for El Capitán: In 2011, Houston Dynamo clinched the cannon with a dramatic 3-2 victory, igniting fan enthusiasm statewide.
• Record-breaking Attendance: A 2017 derby match attracted a whopping 41,000 fans, proving that everything’s bigger in Texas, including soccer fervor.

The fans, of course, play an indispensable role in this derby. Known for their passion, chants, and sometimes humorous banter, they contribute to the match’s electric atmosphere. As one Dynamo supporter shouted,

“We may not have the most trophies, but we’ve got the most heart!”

That sentiment is mirrored by FC Dallas fans who retort with,

“Size matters, and right now, we’ve got El Capitán sitting pretty in Dallas!”

Ah, the sweet sound of friendly jest!

Both teams have seen iconic players step up during these derbies. While FC Dallas fans fondly remember the heroics of Mauro Díaz, Houston Dynamo supporters will never forget Brian Ching’s decisive goals. These star players have etched their names in the Texas Derby folklore, making every game a new chapter in this storied rivalry.

Ultimately, the Texas Derby is more than just a game; it’s a showcase of the unrivaled passion and competitive spirit that define MLS soccer clubs. Whether you’re a die-hard fan or a newcomer, this match promises entertainment, drama, and, perhaps, a cannon blast or two—figuratively, of course!

The Hudson River Derby: New York Red Bulls vs. New York City FC

Being a part of the major league soccer franchises of New York the Hudson River Derby between the New York Red Bulls and New York City is a must-watch. This rivalry, named after the iconic river that geographically separates the two teams, is nothing short of electric. When these two teams clash, the intensity is palpable, and the atmosphere is nothing less than a soccer carnival. Fans from both sides exhibit an unparalleled passion, often making it a spectacle both on and off the field.

The New York Red Bulls, with their storied history in MLS, have often had a slight edge in the number of wins. However, New York City FC, despite being one of the relatively newer mls clubs, has quickly established itself as a formidable opponent. For instance, in their head-to-head encounters, the Red Bulls lead, but NYCFC has had their fair share of memorable victories, including crucial wins that have directly influenced the mls team standings.

Memorable moments in this rivalry include their first-ever encounter in 2015, where the Red Bulls triumphed 2-1, setting the tone for what would become a fiercely contested derby. Fast forward to the dramatic 5-2 thrashing by NYCFC in 2021, which levelled the historical score a bit and added a new chapter to this budding rivalry.

The matches between these teams aren’t just about the points on the table; they are about pride and bragging rights. A perfect illustration of this tension was seen in the 2022 season. When asked about the pressure of the derby, former NYCFC captain Alex Ring stated:

“The Hudson River Derby means everything to the fans and the players. You feel the energy days before the match, and once you’re on the pitch, you know you can’t hold anything back.”

The stats alone tell the story of how competitive these encounters are:

• The Red Bulls have won approximately 53% of their derby matches.
• NYCFC, in comparison, has managed a 39% win rate against their rivals.
• Goals are never in shortage; on average, these matches see about 3.2 goals per game.

Fans eagerly look forward to the stadium atmospheres, with Red Bull Arena and Yankee Stadium becoming battlegrounds. The mls teams’ rosters boast talent with players who often find themselves in the heat of the action. For instance, Red Bulls’ striker Bradley Wright-Phillips left an indelible mark on the derby with his knack for finding the net, whereas NYCFC’s David Villa has also created memorable moments of brilliance.

As the Hudson River Derby continues to grow, the anticipation keeps building. With each new season, fans, analysts, and even neutral supporters mark these dates on their calendars. To put it simply, if there’s one fixture in the MLS schedule that guarantees fireworks, it’s the clash of these two powerhouse mls soccer clubs on the banks of the Hudson River.

Hell is Real Derby: Columbus Crew vs. FC Cincinnati

Dubbed the “Hell is Real Derby,” the rivalry between Columbus Crew and FC Cincinnati has quickly gained momentum. Named after a quirky roadside billboard on Interstate 71 that simply states, “Hell is Real,” the phrase has become emblematic of the fiery rivalry brewing between these two MLS clubs. Both teams are based in Ohio and their close geographic proximity adds extra spice to the matchup. The intensity of this derby keeps rising, and fans eagerly look forward to each encounter. The anticipation is not just confined to the stands; players and coaches feed off the electrifying atmosphere, making each game a spectacle. To put things into perspective, their very first league match in August 2019 ended in a gripping 2-2 tie, setting the stage for future battles. Columbus Crew, with a rich history including an MLS Cup win in 2008, often boasts more seasoned players. On the other hand, FC Cincinnati, one of the newer major league soccer franchises, is fueled by a hunger to establish themselves firmly within the league. But what truly fuels this derby? Passionate fan bases. Columbus Crew’s supporters, known as the Nordecke, are infamous for their undying loyalty and vocal support. FC Cincinnati fans, called “The Bailey,” are equally passionate, proving that a new MLS team can rival established ones in fan fervor. Beyond the stands and chants, the rivalry also has a notable impact on MLS team standings and playoff implications. For instance, Columbus Crew’s 2-1 victory over FC Cincinnati in August 2021 was pivotal in their quest for a playoff spot, underscoring the high stakes often associated with these matches. As Columbus Crew’s captain, Jonathan Mensah, aptly put it:

“These games are more than just points; they are about pride, history, and our fans. You can literally feel the energy when you’re on the pitch.”

From nail-biting finishes to dramatic goals, the “Hell is Real Derby” offers everything a soccer aficionado could hope for. It’s a young rivalry but one that’s rapidly becoming a cornerstone of the MLS experience.

Rocky Mountain Cup: Colorado Rapids vs. Real Salt Lake

When it comes to the Rocky Mountain Cup battles, the Colorado Rapids and Salt Lake (RSL) do not hold back—think of it as a soccer of a Wild West showdown! These matches are known for their intensity, with physical play, passionate fans, and, of course, plenty of drama. If you’re looking to dive into the stats, these games are a treasure trove that significantly impact MLS team rankings and are crucial for any thorough MLS team analysis.

The rivalry officially kicked off in 2005, and since then, it’s been a rollercoaster of emotions for both sets of fans. Real Salt Lake holds the edge overall, having won the Cup numerous times, but the Rapids have shown resilience, making sure RSL never gets too comfortable.